In a recent court filing, the US Department of Justice (DOJ) argued that ordinary citizens should not have the legal right to file lawsuits to enforce federal environmental laws, in particular the Clean Air Act. In effect, they argue that it is solely up to the discretion of the executive branch about how to enforce environmental law, or whether they choose to enforce it at all. This filing seeks to upend how environmental laws like the Clean Air Act and Clean Water Act have been enforced for decades.
Trump DOJ Intervenes in xAI Environmental Case
The filing in question is a result of the DOJ under the Trump Administration intervening in a lawsuit filed by the NAACP against xAI, the company responsible for running the social media platform X (formerly Twitter) as well as the Grok AI. The lawsuit concerns xAI’s “Colossus 2” data center, where the NAACP accuses xAI of running 27 illegal gas turbines in violation of the Clean Air Act. These turbines have resulted in substantial pollution affecting the nearby community, causing health problems and worsening air quality for the local population.
DOJ Argues Against Citizen Lawsuits
Rather than simply arguing on the merits of the case, the DOJ has argued instead that the Clean Air Act only allows citizen lawsuits to be filed in cases where the federal government has chosen to take an enforcement action against an alleged polluter. In other words, they are arguing that if the DOJ, EPA, or other government agency does not choose to pursue charges against a polluter, then an ordinary citizen cannot either.
This is a massive departure from past interpretations of the Clean Air Act, which has resulted in thousands of citizen lawsuits since it was signed into law.
The Role of Citizen Lawsuits in Enforcing Environmental Law
All too often, federal and state environmental authorities have not been sufficient to hold polluters accountable when they violate the law. Even in administrations where environmental laws were strictly enforced, polluters often escaped accountability due to regulators being overwhelmed and underfunded. In these cases, citizen lawsuits have filled much of the gap, ensuring that polluters cannot get away with environmental law violations simply because authorities cannot or will not hold them accountable.
Why This Matters
If accepted, this new interpretation of the law would change all that, cutting off an important tool for keeping the air free of toxic pollutants such as carbon monoxide, nitrogen dioxide, sulfur dioxide, and volatile organic compounds (VOCs). Citizens would need to rely on government authorities solely to enforce the law, effectively gutting environmental regulations by ensuring they would only be enforced at the convenience of the administration in power. This, in turn, would substantially worsen air and water quality, putting people’s health and safety at undue risk.
Williams Cedar is a law firm dedicated to helping clients with personal injury, environmental law, and civil rights cases. We have extensive experience representing the interests of people injured in catastrophic accidents, including fires, explosions and leaks of toxic materials. If you believe we can be of service to you or a loved one, please give us a call at our New Jersey and Pennsylvania offices at (215) 557-0099, or visit our contact page.